Steply

Prove if 9n + 4 is odd, then n is odd

Step by step, with the reason for every step · Proof by contrapositive · Discrete Math

Step by step

The question

Question: prove that if 9n + 4 is odd, then n is odd.

1 Turn it around

An if-then statement means the same as its contrapositive: if not Q, then not P.

We saw it with truth tables.

if P, then Q ≡ if not Q, then not P

Turned around, it says: if n is even, then 9n + 4 is even.

Starting from n is much easier: we know how to write it with letters.

turned around: if n is even, then 9n + 4 is even

Careful!

That swaps the two parts.

It is the converse, a different statement.

Turned around means: swap the parts and put not on both.

Careful: not if n is odd, then 9n + 4 is odd ✗

2 Write it with letters

n is even, so n = 2a, where a is a whole number.

n = 2a

That is what even means.

even = 2 × a whole number

3 Put them in

Now put them in: 9n + 4 becomes 9(2a) + 4.

9n + 4 = 9(2a) + 4

4 Work it out

Open the brackets: 18a + 4.

= 18a + 4

5 Show the form

Every term has a 2 in it.

We take out 2: 2(9a + 2).

= 2(9a + 2)

9a + 2 is a whole number, because whole numbers added and multiplied stay whole.

9a + 2 is a whole number

2 times a whole number: so 9n + 4 is even.

So 9n + 4 is even.

The turned statement is true, so the first one is true too: if 9n + 4 is odd, then n is odd.

The square at the end means: the proof is done.

So: if 9n + 4 is odd, then n is odd. ∎

6 Check

Try n = 1.

Then 9n + 4 is 13: odd.

n = 1: 9n + 4 = 13, odd

And 1 is odd, as the statement says.

Right!

and 1 is odd

Let's look back.

First: turn it around.

Then: write it with letters.

Then: put them in.

Then: work it out.

Then: show the form.

Last: check.

Answer
9a + 2 is a whole number

Your turn

Try this one yourself, then check:

Show the answer
if n is odd, then 7n + 3 is even

More from Proof by contrapositive

The whole lesson: Proof by contrapositive →