Steply

Comparison tests

Calculus 2 · 20 problems, easy to harder

▶ Watch the first one solved

How we do it

  1. For big n
  2. The known series
  3. Compare
  4. Decide
  5. Check

The steps for Does Σ 1/(n^2 + 3) converge. Every solution names its steps, so you always know what comes next.

Worked examples

Does Σ 1/(n^2 + 3) converge Easy

The question

Question: decide if the series converges: the sum of 1/(n² + 3) for n from 1 to infinity.

Σn = 1∞1n2 + 3 =

1 For big n

For big n, only the highest powers matter, top and bottom.

an = 1n2 + 3 ≈ 1n2

2 The known series

We know the sum of 1/n to the 2: a p-series with p = 2.

p is bigger than 1, so it converges.

Σn = 1∞1n2: p = 2 > 1, converges

3 Compare

The bottom has extra plus terms: it is bigger than n².

n2 + 3 > n2

A bigger bottom makes a smaller fraction: every term is smaller than 1/n².

an < 1n2

The direct comparison test: our terms are smaller than terms that add up to a number.

So ours add up to a number too.

smaller than a converging series: converges

4 Decide

So our series converges.

= converges

Careful!

Smaller than a series that diverges tells us nothing.

Compare with one that converges.

Careful: not an < 1n, so it diverges ✗

5 Check

Let's check with a calculator: 100, 1000 and 10000 terms add up to about 0.7303, 0.7393 and 0.7402.

It settles.

Right!

S100 ≈ 0.7303, S1000 ≈ 0.7393, S10000 ≈ 0.7402

Let's look back.

First: for big n.

Then: the known series.

Then: compare.

Then: decide.

Last: check.

Answer
= converges

▶ Watch it solved

Does Σ (n + 1)/(n^3 + 2) converge Medium

The question

Question: decide if the series converges: the sum of (n + 1)/(n³ + 2) for n from 1 to infinity.

Σn = 1∞n + 1n3 + 2 =

1 For big n

For big n, only the highest powers matter, top and bottom.

an = n + 1n3 + 2 ≈ nn3

Cancel: about 1/n².

= 1n2

2 The known series

We know the sum of 1/n to the 2: a p-series with p = 2.

p is bigger than 1, so it converges.

Σn = 1∞1n2: p = 2 > 1, converges

3 Compare

The terms are not simply smaller here.

So use the limit comparison test: divide aₙ by bₙ and let n grow.

lim anbn =

Dividing by 1/n² is the same as times its flip.

= n3 + n2n3 + 2

Top and bottom now have the same highest power with the same number: the limit is 1.

as n → ∞ = 1

The limit is a positive number.

Then the two series do the same thing: both converge, or both diverge.

limit > 0 (a number): both do the same

4 Decide

So our series converges.

= converges

Careful!

Smaller than a series that diverges tells us nothing.

Compare with one that converges.

Careful: not an < 1n, so it diverges ✗

5 Check

Let's check with a calculator: 100, 1000 and 10000 terms add up to about 1.4147, 1.4237 and 1.4246.

It settles.

Right!

S100 ≈ 1.4147, S1000 ≈ 1.4237, S10000 ≈ 1.4246

Let's look back.

First: for big n.

Then: the known series.

Then: compare.

Then: decide.

Last: check.

Answer
= converges

▶ Watch it solved

Does Σ (n^2 + 1)/(n^3 + 3) converge Harder

The question

Question: decide if the series converges: the sum of (n² + 1)/(n³ + 3) for n from 1 to infinity.

Σn = 1∞n2 + 1n3 + 3 =

1 For big n

For big n, only the highest powers matter, top and bottom.

an = n2 + 1n3 + 3 ≈ n2n3

Cancel: about 1 over n.

= 1n

2 The known series

We know the sum of 1/n: a p-series with p = 1.

p is 1, so it diverges.

Σn = 1∞1n: p = 1, diverges

3 Compare

The terms are not simply smaller or bigger here.

So use the limit comparison test: divide aₙ by bₙ and let n grow.

lim anbn =

Dividing by 1/n is the same as times its flip.

= n3 + nn3 + 3

Top and bottom now have the same highest power with the same number: the limit is 1.

as n → ∞ = 1

The limit is a positive number.

Then the two series do the same thing: both converge, or both diverge.

limit > 0 (a number): both do the same

4 Decide

So our series diverges.

= diverges

Careful!

Smaller than a series that diverges tells us nothing.

We need bigger than a diverging one, or the limit test.

Careful: not an < 1n, so it converges ✗

5 Check

Let's check with a calculator: 100, 1000 and 10000 terms add up to about 4.66, 6.96 and 9.26.

It keeps growing.

Right!

S100 ≈ 4.6591, S1000 ≈ 6.9573, S10000 ≈ 9.2594

Let's look back.

First: for big n.

Then: the known series.

Then: compare.

Then: decide.

Last: check.

Answer
= diverges

▶ Watch it solved

Practice

Try each one, then open the answer. Stuck? Open the problem to watch every step.

Easy

  1. does Σ 1/(n^2 + 3) converge
    Answer
    = converges
  2. does Σ 1/(2^n + 1) converge
    Answer
    = converges
  3. does Σ 1/(2n - 1) converge
    Answer
    = diverges
  4. does Σ 5/(n^3 + n) converge
    Answer
    = converges
  5. does Σ 1/(n^2 + n) converge
    Answer
    = converges
  6. does Σ 2/(3^n + 2) converge
    Answer
    = converges
  7. does Σ 1/(3n - 2) converge
    Answer
    = diverges
  8. does Σ 4/(n^2 + 1) converge
    Answer
    = converges

Medium

  1. does Σ (n + 1)/(n^3 + 2) converge
    Answer
    = converges
  2. does Σ 1/(3^n - 1) converge
    Answer
    = converges
  3. does Σ (n + 1)/(n^2 + 2) converge
    Answer
    = diverges
  4. does Σ 2/(n^3 + 5) converge
    Answer
    = converges
  5. does Σ n/(2n^2 - 1) converge
    Answer
    = diverges
  6. does Σ 3/(4^n + 3) converge
    Answer
    = converges
  7. does Σ (2n + 3)/(n^3 + 4n) converge
    Answer
    = converges

Harder

  1. does Σ (n^2 + 1)/(n^3 + 3) converge
    Answer
    = diverges
  2. does Σ (n + 2)/(n^2 + 5n) converge
    Answer
    = diverges
  3. does Σ 1/(2^n - 1) converge
    Answer
    = converges
  4. does Σ (3n - 1)/(n^3 + 1) converge
    Answer
    = converges
  5. does Σ n^2/(n^3 + 7) converge
    Answer
    = diverges